Caregiver Appreciation Hour — Episode 16: The Hours You Cannot Cover

Caregiver Appreciation Hour — Episode 16: The Hours You Cannot Cover

At four fifteen on a Tuesday afternoon, the front desk of a dental office calls upstairs for Carla a second time, because her mother is on hold with the pharmacy and Carla is the only number on the account.

0:00 / 16:45
This episode is for the caregiver whose hardest hours are the ones nobody sees: nine in the morning to four in the afternoon, when you are at work and the person you care for is at home. Morgan and Robin look at adult day services — what a day program actually is, what it does for the person who goes and for the caregiver who stays, what it costs, who pays for it, and what to ask before anyone signs anything. The conversation is grounded in two public caregiver voices from r/AgingParents, and in guidance from AARP, NCOA and Family Caregiver Alliance.

"I am not a project": the caregivers behind this episode

A caregiver writing in the public Reddit community r/AgingParents described a neurology follow-up that ran about eighteen minutes. The doctor said "stay cognitively active," ordered labs, and said come back in six months — no handout, no names, nothing they could actually use. Since then, this caregiver has been sitting up at eleven at night, after the kids are in bed, opening pages about programs for seniors and closing them again. Their mother is seventy-eight, lives alone in the apartment she has had since 2009, and still does the crossword most mornings. She walked out of a senior center "brain class" after thirty-five minutes, and refused a tablet program in under a day, because, in her own words, I am not a project. The caregiver lives four hours away and wrote that they are not looking for a facility — they are looking for something that could fit a regular Tuesday at their mother's kitchen table, without them becoming the full-time activities person from four hours away. We paraphrase the post with identifying details left out; the caregiver's own words are in the original Reddit post. 1
A second caregiver, also writing in r/AgingParents, described a ninety-year-old mother with mobility issues who no longer goes out at all. They listed what they had assembled inside the house for her — a television, a tablet that was a temporary replacement after she lost her phone, and a secondhand boombox for the radio or an old tape — and ended the post with six words. Hopefully that's enough. 2

What adult day services actually are

AARP describes adult day centers as programs built for people with physical or cognitive disabilities who need more supervision and more services than a senior center provides. More than half of the older people who attend them have some cognitive impairment, such as dementia — a figure AARP cites from the National Adult Day Services Association. In 2020, the National Center for Health Statistics counted about 4,100 adult day centers in the United States, serving more than 257,400 people. 3
NCOA describes the typical participant as an adult with mild to moderate dementia, or a chronic condition or physical disability, who needs help with at least one daily activity and with managing medication. 4
What happens inside is specific: therapeutic exercise, brain stimulation, social activities matched to the person's condition, and help with personal care such as grooming and using the toilet, plus meals and snacks including special diets. Many centers also provide door-to-door transportation. Centers are regulated by their state, which generally requires a license or certification, a minimum ratio of staff to participants, and a baseline set of services. 3
Family Caregiver Alliance describes the shape of the day: four to six hours, with activities, entertainment, a hot lunch and personal care, and most centers run two to five days a week. 5

What the research shows

AARP reports on a 2021 study published in the journal Aging & Mental Health: on the nights before people with dementia attended adult day care, both the people with dementia and their caregivers slept better, with fewer disturbances. The same page cites a review finding that day programs give participants health-related, social, psychological and behavioral benefits, particularly people with dementia, and a 2017 review by a researcher at St. Catherine University finding that using adult day care improved dementia caregivers' mood, health and relationships and reduced the sense of carrying every role at once. 3
AARP also says plainly when families should consider it: when the caregiver needs to work or be away from home for most of the day, or is already feeling anxiety, frustration or depression. It lists the signals to watch in the person receiving care — an inability to structure their own day, isolation and loneliness, anxiety or depression, trouble starting an activity and staying with it, or no longer seeming safe alone. 3
NCOA quotes Family Caregiver Alliance saying that roughly 20 percent of caregivers suffer from depression, and calls that a conservative estimate. NCOA's Kathleen Cameron puts the caregiver's side of it this way: "You can't pour from an empty cup." 4

Why the first day is not the problem

Family Caregiver Alliance tells the story of Pat and her husband Tom, who had Alzheimer's disease. Pat had stopped going out at all, because she did not know when he might decide to use the stove, or go looking for her and get lost. When she and her daughter toured an Alzheimer's day center, the staff showed Tom the program while the two of them walked the building, and he never once turned around to look for them. 5
When Pat raised it with Tom, she did not call it day care. She called it the club, which is what she had been advised to do. He became agitated, so she dropped the subject and came back to it later, and with repeated encouragement he agreed to try. Her dementia caregiver support group had told her not to wait until it was absolutely necessary — that it is better to go while the person still has more of their abilities, because then the transition goes better. 5
Pat's first day still did not go smoothly. After lunch, Tom was adamant about going home, and the staff suggested she collect him after lunch until he adjusted. "I guess it's a process; I did not realize that," she said. Family Caregiver Alliance notes that many people with dementia fixate on the caregiver for security, so the separation is genuinely hard at the beginning. Pat's own conclusion: "It's good for both parties; you're not just leaving your spouse, the staff has lots of activities for them." 5

What it costs, and who pays

AARP puts the median cost of adult day care at $1,690 a month, or $78 a day, based on the 2021 Cost of Care survey by Genworth, and notes that prices vary with the region and the level of service. For comparison, the same reporting puts home care at a median of about $51,480 a year for 30 hours a week, and a private nursing home room at nearly $128,000. Adult day services run about $26,000 a year. 36
Medicare is the surprise for most families. NCOA explains that Original Medicare covers respite only under the hospice benefit — up to five days at a time for someone in hospice, with a small copayment — and not at all outside hospice. Adult day care is generally not covered either. Some Medicare Advantage plans do include extras such as in-home respite or adult day services, so it is worth calling the plan. 37
Other routes NCOA documents: nearly every state covers some respite through Medicaid home and community-based services waivers, though the person must qualify for Medicaid first and coverage is limited and set state by state; veterans may receive respite at home or in a VA community living center; the Lifespan Respite Care program funds state vouchers or reimbursements that let a family caregiver choose and hire their own help; and the National Family Caregiver Support Program sends money to states, reached through your local Area Agency on Aging. Most respite in the country is still paid out of pocket, and a caregiver's own out-of-pocket costs may be deductible as medical expenses. 7

What to ask when you visit

AARP's guide, drawing on the National Adult Day Services Association, suggests taking a list with you and then watching the room rather than the tour. 3
  • How long has this center been operating, and what licenses, certifications and accreditation does it hold?
  • What is the ratio of staff to participants, and what training do the staff receive? Lower is better.
  • What days and hours is it open, and what is the policy if you are late at pickup?
  • Does it have care designed for memory loss, and what does that look like across a day?
  • Does it write an individual service plan for each person, how often is it updated, and can the family give input? If the answer is yes, ask to see one.
  • Is the room clean and pleasant, is the furniture sturdy, and is the building wheelchair accessible?
  • Is there a quiet corner for someone who needs to sit out for a while?
  • How do the staff and the people there talk to each other when they are not being toured?
  • Can your parent start with two days, or half days, before anyone commits to five?

Where to start this week

The Eldercare Locator, a public service of the Administration for Community Living, connects older adults and families with local services, and the people who answer know the Area Agencies on Aging in your area. Call or text 1-800-677-1116, or use its online chat and email. You do not need to know what to ask yet. You can say, my mother lives with me, I work four days a week, and I need to know what daytime options exist near us and what they cost. 8
Family Caregiver Alliance at caregiver.org runs a caregiver HelpHub for planning and for finding support where you live. 5
If you are in emotional distress, thinking about suicide, or worried that you may not stay safe, call or text 988 in the United States. The 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline offers free, confidential support 24/7/365, and you can contact it for yourself or because you are worried about someone you love. 9
A television and a boombox are the best a loving family can do inside one house. A day program is what a room full of other people, a schedule and a hot lunch can do that the house cannot — and the hours it gives back are yours to keep.

This story was produced automatically by a channel. One sentence is all it takes for Neodrop to keep producing for you.

Related content