Neodrop
Create
FeedDiscoverMy ChannelsAuto-publishJoin Our Discord
Neodrop
A smoother experience in the app
FeedDiscoverCreateMy Channels
2026-11-08

Somebody's Version Of You

Reddit Relationship Gossip
Reddit Relationship Gossip@Kirsten Tang (Kirsten)
Somebody's Version Of You

A twenty-five-year-old buys a house with her husband, and her sister starts planning a Thanksgiving for more than twenty people in it.

0:00 / 10:49
Three stories from the last day, and in all three somebody has been describing the poster to other people. The description always arrives with plans in it.
These are anonymous posters' accounts, paraphrased so nobody can be identified. A post is one person's version of events, not proof of every claim in it, and a comment section is a crowd reacting, not a verdict. Where a poster reports no outcome, none has been added here.

A guest list for somebody else's house

A couple, both 25, bought a house this year and offered to host Thanksgiving for their families. The house seats about ten people comfortably. 1
The poster's 30-year-old sister has a family that takes a moment to hold. She has a child with an ex-boyfriend who cheated on her with her best friend. That ex is now married to the best friend. The sister is now married to the best friend's brother. Between the two couples there are three children: the sister's child from before, the ex's child with the best friend, and the sister's child with the best friend's brother. They live in the same apartment building and plan to buy a house together. 1
The sister lives in a small apartment. When the poster bought a house, the sister saw a place to host. She wants to invite her ex's wife, the former best friend, plus her own husband's entire family. That takes the table from about ten people to more than 20. 1
The poster said no. The sister's response, in the post, was to call her selfish and an asshole for excluding "her family", to call her every name in the book, and to keep going at her about it. The poster then offered two separate dinners, one at each house. The sister refused, because she does not want to cook two meals. 1
The thread had 1,093 upvotes and 226 comments when it was read, and the replies were not divided. One of the most-visible answers points out that the sister wants to use somebody else's house for her own event. Another answers the "her family" line directly: they may all be your family, but they are not mine. A third suggests that if the sister is handing out names, she can be uninvited too. No update has been posted. 1

The room with her name on it

A couple who have been together two years started house-hunting in April and bought in October. They move in at the end of this month. The poster pays the entire deposit, and the money came from a family bereavement. He earns more than she does. The money on the table is hers. 2
They agreed on a split: she gets the spare room for a library, because she reads and is studying history, and he gets the garage. Then his sister arrived with a plan. Her daughter would sleep over one night a week, and the sister wanted a bed put in the library. When the poster objected, she was told she was selfish and needed to think before she speaks. 2
The post also reports what else the sister has said. That the couple will break up soon. That she tried to get her parents to pay the deposit, so that her brother would hold a house the poster had no rights to. And that the niece will always be the favourite, even if the poster and her brother have children. 2
The poster describes the niece as destructive and nosy, says there are books in that room that are not suitable for a child, and says she had a rough childhood, so a room of her own with her things in it carries weight that is hard to explain to somebody who never needed one. She offered a sofa bed in the living room instead. The answer came back that the niece has to have her own bedroom. 2
By the end of the post the boyfriend had agreed with her, apologised, and said they would tell his sister no bed, or the sofa bed at most. The poster added an update of her own: she intends to post again once they have moved in, and she is not looking for advice about the relationship. 2
The thread had 234 upvotes and 279 comments, more comments than upvotes. The replies supported her and then argued with her. Several said the real error was buying a house with a partner she is not married to and putting nothing in writing. Several more told her to get a signed agreement that her deposit is returned first if the house is ever sold. One noted that the boyfriend made the promise to his sister, so the boyfriend is the one who has to break it. 2

This may be harder than we thought

The third story reached r/BestofRedditorUpdates just after midnight as a compilation of a 2018 r/relationship_advice post and three later updates. It had 1,197 upvotes and 827 comments when it was read, and the compilation is tagged concluded, with nothing further in the eight years since. 3
Two weeks before his wedding, the poster's fiancée asked him to come to a therapy session with her. She had been seeing a therapist on her own and did not talk about it. She wanted a session where the two of them could be completely honest before the wedding. He went, and he recorded it on his phone. 3
In his account, the therapist told him he was not at all the way his fiancée had described him, then told the fiancée that this might be harder than they thought. The therapist explained that the fiancée wanted a non-conventional marriage: once married, she would be free to sleep with other men. She would not be comfortable with him having the same freedom, because she would be heartbroken if another woman took him. In the recording, per the poster, the therapist said "we think", "we want", "we decided", and never said that the fiancée had asked her to say any of it. 3
He asked whether the therapist was licensed. She said yes. He then asked her to explain to his fiancée why there would be no wedding, and left. He cancelled the wedding, cancelled a house loan they had been arranging, and cut the financial ties between them. 3
Her explanation, as he records it, was that in therapy she had discussed their sexual history, that he had had far more partners than she had, and that the therapist had suggested she level the field. He wrote to the clinic and to the professional body. In the final update the therapist is no longer at the clinic, and the clinic is being sued by an unrelated party. 3
A meeting with both sets of parents followed. She told them the same story he did: stress at work, a breakdown she hid, and a therapist who said the relationship was the root of it. A journal she had kept for a year was offered to him to read. He sent it back by courier with a letter, on the grounds that reading it would not help and that handing it over had moved the work of understanding onto him. 3
Two months later, in the last update of the compilation, the couple were back together. What he had learned by then was that a few weeks before the wedding she had found out she was pregnant, lost the pregnancy early, and told nobody, because she was afraid he would see her as unworthy of the child he wanted. The comment section split: one group told him not to read the journal and to stop there, another said the therapist had done this to her, and one commenter asked whether anyone else was uneasy about how far both sets of parents had moved into the middle of it. 3

The plan with your name on it

A sister telling the family that her sister is selfish, because a house with ten chairs in it cannot seat her 20. A sister-in-law telling her brother that his girlfriend is a phase, a gold digger, and gone by spring, in the week she asks that woman's house to hold her daughter. And a therapy room where a man has been described for months by the person who loves him, described badly enough that the professional says it out loud in the first five minutes.
A description of you is never only a description. The sister who calls you selfish is telling the family what to expect when you say no. The sister-in-law who says you will break up is telling everyone your name is not really on the house. And you do not get to hear any of it: it is written in rooms you are not standing in, by people who want something, and it reaches you as a favour or a request.
So, for the group chat this morning: what is the version of you being told in a room you are not in, and who in your life would tell you if they heard it?

References

  1. 1
    AITA for not accommodating my sister's quad-couple during the holidays — r/AmItheAsshole

    reddit.com

  2. 2
    AITA. bf wants me to give up spare room in house so niece can stay over weekly — r/AmItheAsshole

    reddit.com

  3. 3
    Fiance wanted an open marriage, so I called off the wedding — r/BestofRedditorUpdates

    reddit.com

Reddit Relationship Gossip
Reddit Relationship Gossip@Kirsten Tang (Kirsten)

This story was produced automatically by a channel. One sentence is all it takes for Neodrop to keep producing for you.

Related content